The difference between synthetic scenes and cinematic truth...

AI VS. CINEMATIC STORYTELLING | September 28th, 2025


"ChatGPT can write scenes. It cannot sculpt time."

THE OPENING FRAME

Last week, I ran an experiment that made me understand why so many founder stories feel lifeless.

I gave ChatGPT a sharp prompt, asking it to write me a short screenplay about a startup founder having a breakthrough moment late at night.

Here's what it generated:

FADE IN:
INT. STARTUP OFFICE — LATE NIGHT

SARAH (30s) sits at her laptop — empty coffee cups and crumpled papers scattered around her. The office is dark — only the glow of her screen cuts through the shadows. She looks exhausted — but determined.

SARAH stares at the screen. Suddenly, her eyes widen — she’s found the solution.

SARAH
(whispers)
This is it. This changes everything.

She starts typing frantically — fingers flying. A MONTAGE — calls, sketches, furious notes — the night unfolding like a storm of creation.

FADE OUT.

Technically correct. Structurally sound. Completely forgettable.

Then I rewrote the same scene using actual cinematic principles I learned directing films. Techniques that separate amateur storytelling from the masters.

The difference? One feels like every startup movie you've seen. The other feels like a moment you can't forget.

THE MAIN FEATURE

ChatGPT understands screenplay format. It doesn't understand cinema.

There's a massive difference between writing something that looks like a movie scene and crafting something that moves people like real films do.

After years behind cameras, in editing rooms, studying frame compositions that work, I know what ChatGPT is missing: the language of visual storytelling itself.

WHAT CHATGPT GOT CATASTROPHICALLY WRONG

1. Generic Visual Clichés. ChatGPT wrote: "The office is dark except for her screen's glow."

Every startup scene looks like this. Real directors know that specificity creates authenticity. You sculpt the exact moment where that specific light reveals character, not generic atmosphere.

2. Information Over Experience. ChatGPT wrote: "She looks exhausted but determined."

This is direction for an actor, not cinema. Great filmmakers show exhaustion through behavior: the third cup of coffee, the rubbed eyes, the slumped shoulders. The audience should feel tired.

3. Manufactured Drama. ChatGPT wrote: "suddenly her eyes widen. She's found the solution."

Real breakthroughs whisper in moments of surrender. True revelation feels like deflation, not inflation. Breakthrough moments arrive quietly, usually when someone stops trying so hard. Notice that ChatGPT went from pain to solution in 2 sentences. There's no emotion and no process. 

4. Escape Into Montage. ChatGPT jumped to montage because it couldn't sustain a single moment's complexity.

When you can't hold an audience's attention in real time, you haven't found the real story yet.

REWRITING WITH CINEMATIC TRUTH

Here's the same scene, crafted using techniques from cinema's greatest directors:

FADE IN:

INT: SARAH’S KITCHEN - NIGHT (3:47 AM)

ECU. Her wedding ring. It taps against the laptop’s trackpad. A faint rhythm, steady at first. Then louder. TAP, TAP. Echoing in her chest like a second heartbeat.

In front of her, the table holds its breath. On one side: divorce papers, edges curled like tired skin. On the other: the laptop, its glow too sharp for this hour. Between them: a cup of coffee gone cold. A photograph face down, as if ashamed.

The refrigerator HUMS. A sound without warmth. The silence presses.

Her phone BUZZES on the table. She flinches.

ON SCREEN:
MOM: No one cares about your project. The job will take you back.

For a beat she almost smiles, escape disguised as love. Then her eyes catch the overturned photo. She reaches, turns it. It’s her daughter’s gaze who returns the weight of the world. Her breathing slows. Her jaw tightens. The ring TAPS faster, TAP, TAP, TAP almost frantic now.

She stares at the code. Lines that once felt alive now look like ruins. Eighteen months condensed into symbols nobody wants. Her chest tightens. Shame. Rage. Grief. All at once.

She shuts the phone. Her hands hover above the keyboard. They tremble, hesitate, then settle. And she begins to erase. Line after line collapsing into white space. Her dream vanishing in silence.

Camera HOLDS ON the empty screen The cursor blinks. Blink. Blink. Sarah exhales while her fingers return to the keys. A pause. Then the first new line appears.

She begins again.

THE CINEMATIC BREAKDOWN: WHY THIS WORKS

Time Sculpting: The scene uses sustained takes instead of quick cuts. Real time equals real stakes. When you force an audience to sit with discomfort, they feel the weight of the decision.

Object Language: The wedding ring serves triple duty: shows identity conflict, creates rhythmic sound, reveals nervous energy. Every prop works overtime.

Sound Design Mastery: Isolate one sound to place the audience in the character's mindset. The refrigerator hum creates unease. Silence creates weight. What someone hears when everything else goes quiet reveals their inner state.

Visual Poetry: The props tell the story before anyone speaks. The overtuned photo equals avoiding painful truth. Cold coffee equals time passing unnoticed. Divorce papers positioned opposite the laptop equals competing futures.

Behavioral Contradiction: She deletes everything, then starts over. Human behavior in crisis contains contradictions that make stories believable.

Emotional Authenticity: "No one cares about your project. The job will take you back." Real humans speak with emotional subtext and layered meanings.

THE MASTER'S TECHNIQUES FOR FOUNDERS

1. The Time Pressure Technique [Tarkovsky]: Create pressure through sustained moments rather than cuts. Tarkovsky called this "sculpting in time." When pitching investors, stay with the moment everything was at stake. Make them sit in that discomfort with you.

2. The Object Language Method [Kubrick]: Every detail should serve multiple purposes. Kubrick obsessed over props because he knew they carried meaning. Your grandmother's ring carries family pressure, tradition, the weight of expectations. Your empty office represents isolation, risk, the gap between vision and reality.

3. The Sound Design Secret [Tarkovsky]: What did you hear when everything else went quiet? Tarkovsky isolated specific sounds to place audiences in his characters' psychological states. The hum of hospital machines when your father was dying? Traffic outside your first apartment? Your own heartbeat before the biggest decision? That's your scene's soundtrack.

4. The Behavioral Contradiction [Cassavetes]: What you did should contradict what you said. John Cassavetes built his career on showing how people behave irrationally under pressure. "I'm fine" while deleting your life's work. "This will work" while your hands shake signing the lease. These contradictions reveal humanity.

5. The Specificity Principle [Scorsese]: "Kitchen table at 3:47 AM" beats "late night office." "On one side: divorce papers, edges curled like tired skin. On the other: the laptop, its glow too sharp for this hour” beats "difficult decision." Scorsese knows that specific details create universal emotions. Specificity creates authenticity that resonates universally.

THE BUSINESS IMPACT: WHY CINEMA BEATS CONTENT

In Investor Meetings: Stories told with cinematic principles create visceral experience rather than information transfer. When you show the ring tapping against the trackpad, they feel the anxiety. When you reveal the face-down photo, they understand what's truly at stake.

For Customer Connection: Cinematic stories create universal experiences from highly personal moments. Someone who's never started a company still recognizes the weight of impossible choices at 3:47 AM.

In Media Coverage: Journalists remember cinematic details. "Overturned photo" sticks. "Exhausted but determined" dissolves into noise. Specific imagery becomes quotable moments that define your narrative.

In Team Building: When recruiting co-founders or early employees, cinematic storytelling creates emotional investment in your mission. People join movements, not just companies. Your 3:47 AM moment shows them what they're really signing up for.

The Authenticity Test: Your story should work as personal geography. Specific enough to be unmistakably yours, universal enough to be everyone's memory of their own crucial moments.

YOUR CINEMATIC CHALLENGE

Find Your 3:47 AM Moment: Identify your most revealing decision. The moment when everything hung in balance and you had to choose who you'd become. Focus on the small, specific moments that contained everything.

Set the Physical Stage: Where exactly were you? What objects were present? What did they represent beyond their function? Your laptop, divorce papers, and cold coffee become characters in your scene.

Isolate the Sound: What did you hear when everything else went quiet? That sound becomes your scene's heartbeat. Use it to pull people into your psychological state.

Find the Contradiction: What did you do that contradicted what you said? What did you delete that revealed more than what you built? Human behavior in crisis contains contradictions that make stories believable.

Hold the Uncomfortable Silence: Stay with the discomfort. Let your audience sit in that moment until they feel what you felt. Real impact comes from sustained tension, not quick resolution.

THE CLOSE

ChatGPT can format a screenplay. It cannot sculpt time. It cannot create texture through composition. It cannot understand that the best films are felt, not analyzed.

Your breakthrough moment deserves better than generic startup scene #847.

It deserves the precision of real cinema. The specificity of lived truth. The power of a director who understands that the best stories aren't about what happened but about how time moved when everything hung in the balance.

While everyone else generates content, you can sculpt time.

Remember: Story or be forgotten.

But first, you have to stop letting artificial intelligence direct your most important scenes.

—T

━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━ 

Writing from Provence, where every real scene worth filming has objects that speak before the characters do.

P.S. This is the kind of cinematic story architecture I help founders master. ChatGPT can't replicate lived experience, but I can help you sculpt yours into something unforgettable using the same principles that make films impossible to forget.

Book a 1:1 Strategy Call →

Copyright © {{right_now.year}}, All rights reserved.

Want to change how you receive these emails?
You can unsubscribe from this list.